1x1 - "Is Bloody Mabel the Angel of Death?”

June 28, 2022

Watch out for knitting needles and check out Elliott Gould and Waj Ali discussing Bloody Mabel with host Ali Stroker on One Killer Question: The Only Murders In The Building aftershow.

1x2 - "It's Totally Amy Schumer, isn't it?"

June 28, 2022

A new celebrity resident of the Arconia. A new suspect! Michael Cyril Creighton and Da’Vine Joy Randolph join host Ali Stroker to ask: is Amy Schumer guilty? or totally guilty? on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.

1x3 - “Why does everyone hate you?”

July 5, 2022

Tim Kono and Bunny kinda get the short end of the stick, huh? Well, not anymore! Join Ali Stroker with Julian Cihi (Tim Kono) and Jayne Houdyshell (Bunny) to hear the victims in Only Murders In The Building get the last word.

1x4 - "What’s with all the daddy issues?"

July 12, 2022

Dads. They’re really a thing this season, huh? One Killer Question tackles the perils of paternity with host Ali Stroker, Ryan Broussard (Will) and superfan Elliott Gould in the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.

1x5 - "Wanna play son of Sam?”

July 19, 2022

The game’s afoot and it’s time to ask: who do we trust? Host Ali Stroker is joined by Dan Oreskes (Marv) and superfans Hayley Law and Waj Ali on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.

1x6 - “Our leads make terrible relationship decisions. That’s not a question.”

July 26, 2022

Charles, Mabel and Oliver may be good sleuths. But their personal lives are a mess. Host Ali Stroker talks with Chris Redd and Melissa Rivers to dig into some poor life choices on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.

1x7 - “Theo. Huh?”

August 2, 2022

What if the man who killed your best friend saves your life… and maybe isn’t such a bad guy? Host Ali Stroker, James Caverly (Theo) and Ryan Broussard (Will) dig into all things Theo on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.

1x8 - “Who’s the ultimate Arconia blackout buddy?”

August 9, 2022

The power’s out and a killer is on the loose. Which Arconia resident do you turn to? Host Ali Stroker chats blackout buddies with Melissa Rivers and Ricky Dillon on One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.

1x9 - Is it gonna be OK?

August 16, 2022

The case is heading to a close (we think?). But even if the killer is found, are our leads gonna be OK? Join host Ali Stroker and superfans Waj Ali and Hayley Law in One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.

1x10 - “I know who did it!”

August 23, 2022

The killer’s identity is no longer a question. But we’ve still got a big one left to answer. Join host Ali Stroker, Jayne Houdyshell (Bunny), and Adina Verson (Poppy) on the S2 finale of One Killer Question, the Only Murders in the Building aftershow.

Michael Cyril Creighton

Self - Host